New York on Screen: Some Pet Peeves
What are the media stereotypes of your hometown or current residence that bug you the most?
Many media depictions of New York head in one of two directions: we’re either below 125th Street and wealthy, or above and in an urban nightmare. So there’s Sex and the City, Friends, and endless others on one hand, or Law and Order on the other. I’ve now lived here on and off for seven years, yet have completely missed both New Yorks.

One of the most annoying and seemingly common NYC-on-screen myths is of the rent-controlled apartment. This is conveniently necessary for shows like Friends, to explain how people who are meant to be “just like you” live in a place that you will never be able to afford. One would think that there’s a separate section of Craigslist for rent-controlled apartments, or that one’s offered the chance to flip a coin upon arrival in the city, and if it’s heads, congrats, your rent is controlled below $600/month.
Also, because so many New Yorkers on screen are wealthy, they take cabs everywhere. Or on the off chance that they head down to the subway, it’s filthy, and full of odd, threatening people. I spend too much time on the subway, and resent it accordingly, but it’s also the lifeblood of the city, and way more interesting, vibrant, and cultured than television would allow one to believe. House guests always find a ride on our local train, the #7, fascinating, hearing multiple languages, seeing all ages, classes, races, and styles.

And because so many screen New Yorkers take cabs, their commutes are quick, and they have an endless supply of free time. The entire cast of Friends appear to work within half a block of Central Perk, or they must, because nobody complains about spending an hour on the 4 because it decided to run local, or on the G because the MTA is doing work on the tracks. No wonder they’re all so happy, without those pesky commutes.
Then there’s the Bronx, and a stream of perpetual murders, gang fights, and juvenile delinquency in progress. Even though in reality almost two thirds of the population of New York City are non-White or White Hispanic, not too many of them seem to be below 125th Street on screen, except when delivering a pizza, washing dishes in a kitchen, working in a Chinatown sweatshop, or working as a cop. Instead, it seems that they’re all hanging out in the Bronx or dodgy areas of Brooklyn or Queens, committing crimes, or covering up for others who are doing so.
How about you? What media stereotypes of your home bug you?





Recent Comments